Monday, April 4, 2011

Controlling Characters

         Are you operating a puppet show or writing a story?  Becoming a control freak when it comes to writing your characters can leave them predictable and stereotypical--or shall we say boring. 

          Outlines and character sketches are good tools to use in shaping your main characters, but don't just stop there.  Give them history, aspirations, and motivation. The reader doesn't have to know every detail--only what's important to the story.  You should know your characters like you know those who are closest to you.  At the same time you should allow characters to make interesting choices and do unexpected things. 

          When Pinocchio was just a puppet he was lifeless and wooden.   When he became a real boy he became interesting.  Now, there was a story to tell.  Perhaps it's time to cut the strings from your characters and let them surprise you as they take on a life of their own.



***********

98 comments:

mooderino said...

Good point, well made.
cheers,
mood
Moody Writing

D. Heath said...

I agree. Life is interesting and unpredictable. Therefore controlled events and characters doesn't mimic the spontaneity of people or engage the reader. I would love to write a fiction book in the future, so this is a great tip!
Social Science Medley

Madeleine said...

Great analogy. I use pics to get an idea of my characters too. :O)

welcome to my world of poetry said...

A great c word Lee.
I usually use myself or life expereiences for my writing.

Good challenge though only day 3.

Yvonne.

Charmaine Clancy said...

Good use of C :)

Wagging Tales - Blog for Writers

salarsenッ said...

Very true. They need guidance but freedom...just like raising kids. A rich history is nice, too.

Mercy a.k.a Rogue said...

It's true. If you over think, or push too hard it shows in your characters. You need to leave a little to your readers imagination and their take on the story.

Umamaheswari.A said...

hmm..that was a fabulous idea.Reminded me of my puppet
http://umaspoembook.blogspot.com/2011/04/haiku-puppet.html

bendedspoon said...

Cutting the strings is really interesting -- even the ones that we tied our own selves where we limit the circumference that we can navigate.

Here's to breaking free! :)

Nofretiri said...

Love that picture with Pinocchio, very visually! :-)

If you wonder, what my thoughts of writing checklists are, have a look at my today's post: C for Checklists

Wish you a good start into the new week & happy writing!

Karin @ Nofretiris Dream Of Writing

li said...

Good reminder Lee. It's easy to get trapped into predictability for a character. The fun of reading a good story/novel is in being surprised and wondering what will happen next.

Alex J. Cavanaugh said...

I always create detailed character sketches before I begin writing.

Angeline said...

I never have control over my characters. I write for about 10,000 words and then they take over. I love it when characters do something unexpected; it keeps me on my toes!

Rhonda @Laugh Quotes said...

Good advice and suggestions. I will think about this when I write my next post. Thanks Lee.

Ellie said...

Great advice. Unless your character comes alive in your head and starts telling you what to write, you're not doing it right!

Ellie Garratt

mybabyjohn said...

I'm going to have to make up a little book of all the helpful hints and tips I am picking up.
Great post.

Jess said...

I loved this post! Short and simple with a great point! Thanks, Arlee :)

Nate Wilson said...

In my puppet show, the marionettes are always rebelling against me. Which is all well and good until they find the knife I hid nearby for the end of the third act...

Ruth @Welcome to me said...

That is a great idea.

DEZMOND said...

cut the strings, just don't let them go too crazy :)))

Carol Kilgore said...

Keep them on a long, long leash.

Jessica Bell said...

Ah, I cut my characters' string a long time ago! They run wild! :o)

Jessica @ The Alliterative Allomporph

fantasy queen said...

i'm working on a story now, i am my best muse... my character is more like me. i've been known to be many things and predictable isn't one of them.

Martha (MM) said...

I'm not much of a writer myself, but I do read a lot. I don't like predictable characters unless I'm reading a series and then I love the predictability, it makes me feel like I personaly know the character.

Thanks for stopping by. I'm still totally amazed at the amount of participants for this challenge!

L.G.Smith said...

I like to know who my characters are before I start writing, but they always surprise me by the end of the story with the things they think and do.

becca said...

good point and i'm having lots of fun with this challenge

Jennifer Gladen said...

Great tips! I'm new to this A-to Z challenge. Just learned about it and signed up 2 of my blogs. SO i have a little catch up work to do. As requested by your cute white rabbit, I'll leave my links in this comment:

My Author Blog - www.jgladen.blogspot.com

Random Thoughts about God
www.randomthoughtsaboutgod.blogspot.com

Gregg said...

Sounds like very good advice. Keep the characters light and loose!


Gregg Metcalf
Colossians 1:28-29

Gospel-driven Disciples

L. Diane Wolfe said...

I always outline my characters - their background, personality type, motivation, looks, strengths, weaknesses, family & friends...

Dafeenah said...

Great advice! My characters usually have a lot of backstory. I always doubt myself as to whether I have told enough or too much. It's a balance I am still working on achieving.

Dafeenah

Karen Walker said...

Yup - so true.
Karen

Brianna said...

Great advice, Lee!

Julie Jordan Scott said...

I am an actor as well as a writer and I love how character development is so similar across different creative endeavors.

Am loving this A to Z challenge!

My entry for today...

Arlee Bird said...

I thank everyone for the comments so far. You are all so encouraging. Now keep making friends, learning new things, and be entertained. I will be by to see each of you before too long I hope.

Lee

Heidi Windmiller said...

Great advice!

My problem is going to far in letting them control me sometimes. They take me off on tangents not related to the story. But it is still useful--I get to know them better, and I get to use the delete button.

Sherri said...

I think I know my characters better than real people in my social circle. I used to have imaginary friends as a child and I recently realized that as a writer - I still do!

TheyCallMeVarmit said...

You make a really good point, and one I completely agree with!

shah wharton said...

I have a lot of back story, its where to fit it in the story that I struggle with - great post - I'm here from the A2Z Challenge stopping by and I think I'm gonna follow!. http://wordsinsync.blogspot.com/2011/04/z-blogging-challenge-april-2011-c.html Shah. X

M.J. Fifield said...

I used to like to think that I was the puppet master but it turns out that the inmates were running the asylum. So now they tell me their story and I put it down on paper.


M.J. Fifield
My Pet Blog

Laura Marcella said...

Great point. Love the analogy to Pinnochio. I always plan my characters and know exactly who they were before the start of page 1. It's not necessarily anything I'll include in the story, but it's important for me to know!

Joe Richardson said...

I think that first draft is as much about finding character as it is discovering story. Some writers talk about plot and character as if they walk side by side, but never touch. Never understood that. Plot shapes character, just as certainly as characters move the plot, yes?

As for cutting the strings--absolutely. I know a story's working when a character surprises me with a word or deed that wasn't planned, but just feels right. Love moments like that!

Thanks for the post,
Joe
Dead Reckoning

Name: Luana Krause said...

Good analogy. I'm a puppeteer, but no offense taken.

Stephen Tremp said...

Good post ... let the characters develop themselves. Often the emerge as the story is written. Minor characters can become major ones and fan favorites.

Ella said...

I love this; yes, cutting the cord is truly what makes all the difference!

Rosalind Adam said...

I love the puppet analogy but if I remember the story accurately, Pinocchio became more interesting when his strings were cut and he was able to be naughty. Maybe it's that we like a bit of spunk in our characters.

Grandpa said...

I'll go with that. I enjoy a character that's alive and kicking - so set them free!

Grandpa
Life on The Farm

V.R. Leavitt said...

Great advice! Like that you used the Being John Malkovich cover too. :-)

Nf1andprek-whisper said...

being john ... was the weirdest movie.. but interesting.. I have just decided to begin a charachter sketch and outline of a new book I am making up.... so this group of writers may be helpful... this time around.

Empty Nest Insider said...

Great advice Lee! Characters are like children; you nourish their bodies and souls, and have to know when it's time to set them free.

Julie

fredamans said...

Great use of C! You are very correct in saying well-rounded characters is what makes the story.

Nicole said...

That is so right and character control is very important, I agree.

Unfortunately, I guess I'm among those who are doing the puppet show thing because I'm not always interested in the background or history of a character for some of the stories that I create for my films and/or videos.

I'm usually just interested in the current conflict or task at hand rather than what happened to these characters in the past.

One of my films that have not reached the script stage yet, has more of that "writing a story" that you are referring to in that one because the main character's history affect his behavior and affect his actions in the present and also influence decisions that he needs to make about the future, so I figure (in my own work)....if it's necessary for the story, then I write a story but if controlling characters are unnecessary, then I do the puppet show.

Since many of my projects are very short, spanning maybe 30 minutes in length or less, around 10 minutes, I don't always find it necessary to make characters with deep rooted histories and such.

Nicole
The Madlab Post

Marjorie said...

I love that you used the cover for Being John Malcovich. That movie was really strange but was full of character.

Donna Weaver said...

Love this post. I remember when Jo Rowling was interviewed toward the end of her writing of "Deathly Hallows" and Sometimes our characters aren't even who WE think they are. Like a parent with a child, we need to let them use their wings so they can fly.

Misha said...

Hehehe yeah... the only puppet when it comes to the writing is me. I'm not operating under the misconception that I'm in control.

;-P

Kidding, I have some control over the story. But I can't make my characters do anything.

blogger sam said...

good addition with the Pinocchio thing at the end, I like it.

Munir said...

Very nice and helpful post. I agree with you,charecters are good if they have a certain direction to go towards. In real life though, we don't like controlling people do we?

lbdiamond said...

I love the topic of this post--I agree 100%...let the character make their choices and see where the story goes. Fun!

Jamie (Mithril Wisdom) said...

I really enjoy making outlines and back stories to my characters, but I do try my best to let their stories unfold as I write. It tends to not work though :P

Debra Ann Elliott said...

Great, great, great!

Michael Di Gesu said...

Excellent advice, Lee!

The Golden Eagle said...

Great advice!

Laura T. said...

I've posted my "C" post.

http://mom2nick.typepad.com/heres_whats_new/2011/04/c-is-for-crayon-color-.html

Thanks for looking.
Laura T.

Pearson Report said...

Sage advice!

If only I could cut the strings off me - and let "me" take on a life of its own - then we would have a story.

Smiles,
Jenny

www.jennypearson.com

Patricia Stoltey said...

Donald Maass even says to find something that your character would never do in a millions years, then make him do it. I love that idea...it's like leading your character into a trap and then sitting back to see what happens next.

AlexOngNYC said...

Alex from Breakfast Every Hour was here.

Lisa said...

I am learning sooooo much already.

Lisa
InspiredbyLisa

L'Aussie said...

Great post on controlling characters and clever to bring in Pinocchio. Hope you're enjoying the challenge!

Thanks for visiting Columbia. D is for ...?

Denise<3

L'Aussies Travel Blog A - Z Challenge Posts

Steve Miller, Writer of Stuff said...

I have run an RPG campaign for over a decade now, and I keep having to remind myself that I NEED to write and develop back stories for every character that starts to become a recurring figure (NPC-wise... the players are on their own as far as back stories.)

While I have one player who keeps me honest--such as reminding me how many years have passed between various events--I have screwed up a couple of times by confusing one character with another, or by forgetting a key event I mentioned in a character's background but never wrote down. It's easy to revise a novel or story before it's been published, but in the interactive environment of an RPG, the error is a little harder to recover from. (And then there's the time I messed up a character in a publication, because I didn't bother checking the back story that I myself had written. In my arrogance, I didn't check my own previous writings, and the editor trusted I knew what I was talking about.... Oooops.)

Penned Pebbles said...

Very informative C post! The A-Z challenge is keeping me busy busy busy! :-)

Penned Pebbles

Paula Martin said...

Interesting post, Lee. When I first start writing a story, my characters may be as wooden as Pinocchio - but I don't write their character sketch, THEY do that as they become alive to me. They develop their own personalities, not a personality I've fore-ordained for them, and sometimes a backstory that I didn't know about until they told me. I love the way they can surprise me at times!
http://paulamartinpotpourri.blogspot.com/

Melissa Kline said...

Hi Arlee!Great post! I am very passionate about my characters and sometimes wonder if they are controlling me or if I am controlling them. Very interesting!

~Melissa
Reflections on Writing

Mojo said...

Reading this reminded me of Pirandello's "Six Characters in Search of an Author" - the difference between the Characters, behaving authentically according to their natures, and the Actors, clumsily aping them from imperfect observations...

Excellent post!

LoneIslander said...

Good stuff

Stephen T. McCarthy said...

BOID ~
I generally take each of my characters out for a night on the town. I mean, how can you say you REALLY know your characters until you've gotten loaded with them?

(Plus, it's always a good excuse for going out on the town.)

The plain truth of the matter is: Until you know what your characters would do or say while intoxicated, you do not really know your characters.

It has always amazed me how few writers have grasped this simple but crucial concept.

~ D-FensDogg
'Loyal American Underground'

Vanilla Mama said...

Awesome - Glad I found you through a fellow blogger doing the A-Z Challenge. Hope I am not too late to sign up - I'll catch up tonight!

Hold my hand: a social worker's blog said...

Great **C**, Lee!

Doris

Jolene Perry said...

My people RARELY do what I think they're going to when I sit down to write. Rarely.

Fourth Grade Teacher said...

Thank you for stopping by Pawny's Pen!

Your post is so true! I created a character prior to NaNoWriMo one year, and she was so incredibly boring that I killed her off in the first sentence. (On the plus side, that turned into the book I just published, because the mystery began with "why would anyone want to kill off someone who's that boring?")

I look forward to reading the rest of your posts this month!

Kathi Oram Peterson said...

This is great! Thanks for the reminder to let my characters be themselves! That's when the magic happens.

Diana said...

Like the characters in my dreams! Always surprising me even though I think that I know them!
Love Di ♥

Kari Marie said...

Excellent point!

erica and christy said...

learning to leave aspects of characters out of the story can be challenging, but knowing those details so very necessary! christy

Sharon K. Mayhew said...

Great point, Lee! Your characters have to be interesting...more interesting than real life, so they can capture the hearts of their audience. :)

Miriam Drori said...

Oh yes! Great advice. I'm off to look for the scissors.

B. Miller said...

Great post, I completely agree, Lee! Thanks for sharing.

Marinela Reka said...

Great stuff, very good point, Lee!

Short Poems

Niki said...

Great post and yes I am enjoying the challenge :o) It's heaps better keeping the posts simple.

Jeffrey Beesler said...

I had a manuscript where the antagonist was set. Then this not-before-seen character shows up out of the blow and convinces me to demote my at the time current antagonist to mere henchman. I never looked back. Letting characters flow like that can open up so many possibilities!

Her highness, Samantha Vérant said...

How true, because sometimes my characters (er, me when I threat them) get out of control!

Michelle in a shell said...

Great point- thanks for pointing this out. I should start compiling your pointers for the day I decide to start writing!

SweetMarie83 said...

Well said! When I'm creating characters, I write down the basics but eventually, they seem to have a mind of their own and I just go with it!

Dafeenah said...

Hi Arlee, you left me a comment and said something that I am not quite sure what it meant so I wanted to ask because I think it would be so much easier than what I currently do.

You said you're not subscribing and that I could email you back from the notification. I just wanted to sort of clarify what that meant.

Does it mean that if I reply to the email I receive from your comment it goes directly to you?

I so did not know that. If I am understanding that correctly, then that is very cool and I will be using that in the future.

Cherie Reich said...

Great post, Lee! You have to breathe life into characters. :)

Lynette Killam said...

I do thorough outlines of the characters I write, but do not use these parametres to imprison them. Few things are more fun in writing than having a character surprise its author by bursting out in a way that wasn't anticipated.

It is this spontaneity that makes a character come to life...

T.F. Walsh said...

Great blog topic, and I'm sure everyone has a different approach to developing characters. I have a general idea about a character and try to expand on that through their backstory. If they are a loner, I ask them why. If it is because they lost parents from a young age, I ask them what happened. etc. It works for me.
Oh, and this is my first comment on your blog...:) I'll be back.

Alex F. Fayle said...

Too much backstory and I get bored and too little leaves me without much to write about. I've discovered that if I pick a way of viewing the world for each character they can then surprise me in a way that serves the story and fits into the overall themes of whatever I'm writing.

For example in my current WIP, one character notices buildings and see people as constructions. Another sees people only in how they can help her get to her goals, so only sees the details she wants to.

Elizabeth West said...

Yes! This is hard for beginning writers because I think we tend to be imitative at first, as we practice and get our legs under us.

I love when they live and breathe. I had one character in my last book that came out of nowhere. I liked him a lot. He was a joy to write.

Arlee Bird said...

whoa, I let these wonderful comments get away from me without acknowledging them. Thank you all! I have gotten so far behind, but I'm having delirious fun with A to Z and hope you are to.

And Rosalind, when I reread this after it posted I too realized the same thing you pointed out but I wasn't about to rewrite it. Besides we don't know what happens after he becomes real!

Lee