My A to Z Themes in the past have covered a range of topics and for 2024 the theme is a personal retrospective that I call "I Coulda Been" which is in reference to my job and career arc over my lifetime. I'll be looking at all sorts of occupations that I have done or could have done. Maybe you've done some of these too!
Sunday, December 1, 2024
As Autumn Draws to a Close ( #BOTB & #IWSG )
Another autumn is rapidly coming to an end. Just a few more weeks and winter will be here. Are you feeling it yet where you are? I'm in Los Angeles so autumn-schmautumn. Hope you had a wonderful Thanksgiving. Ours was small with only three in attendance this year, but the food was fantastic! And I cooked it all. I also cooked up the following autumn musical Battle...
Battle of the Bands
Battle of the Bandsisthe blogging event started byFar Away Seriesand now hosted byStMcC Presents Battle of the Bands. This event happens each month on the 15th and on some there is also a Battle on the 1st of the month. My blog is one of those with a second Battle excepting over these summer months. The premise is simple: Listen to the songs presented below and then in the comments vote for your favorite and tell us why you liked it. Then visit the links listed near the bottom of this post for more Battle action.
Diana in the Autumn Wind
Once again I delve into the psychedelic past of Lee's Basement to dig up another treasure from the cut-out bins. It was early 1970's when I was regularly foraging cut-out record bins wherever I found them. I can't recall where or when I acquired the vinyl album of The National Gallery performing musical interpretations of the paintings of Paul Klee, but I was onboard as soon as I laid eyes on it. Since I was becoming more aware of art at that time the concept of the album intrigued me. The psychedelic artwork of the cover certainly drew me in as well.
The National Gallery was not so much of an actual group as it was a classical/jazz/rock project by jazz artist Chuck Mangione and Cleveland record producer Roger Karshner. They co-wrote the songs and brought in various artists to record the album. This was a favorite album for me back in those days and received frequent spins on my turntable. I still have the vinyl in my collection and listening to it in recent days it still sounds great. I took good care of my vinyls.
Here are two versions of the song "Diana in the Autumn Wind" which appears on the National Gallery album and then later on an instrumental jazz album by Chuck's brother Gap Mangione. Which do you enjoy most?
Time to Vote! Don't let winter come before you vote. Battles are no fun without you the reader participating. Hopefully you have an opinion of some kind. You don't have to know about music to have an opinion since it all comes down to your own personal taste.
Please vote on your favorite by letting us know your choice in the comment section and tell us why you prefer the version you chose. Then after you've finished here, please visit the other blogs listed below who may or may not be participating this time around. And if you've put up your own BOTB contest let us know that as well so we can vote on yours. I don't know if anyone else will be doing a Battle this time around, but you can still check out these sites. Here are some other places where you might find BOTB posts: StMcC Presents Battle of the Bands 'MIKE'SRAMBLINGS' 'Curious as a Cathy' Sound of One Hand Typing Jingle, Jangle, Jungle
December 4 question - Do you write cliffhangers at the end of your stories? Are they a turn-off to you as a writer and/or a reader?
I do sometimes like ambiguous endings and have written such when that seemed to be the most appropriate way to deal with a story. An absolute cliff-hanger ending that demands resolution in a sequel of some sort is fine so long as there will be some upcoming book or part of the story and readers are on board with that. Personally I don't like investing too much of my time and energy into a series that goes on too long. I know some people seem to like this sort of thing, but not me so much. I like to move on to new stories and have variety.
If the book or story is a stand alone then I think the reading audience deserves a more absolute resolution to the story being told. Really though, I guess it depends. Depends on what? Hmm--let me think on that. I'll tell you next month,
Do you prefer to just wrap things up and move on when you read something? When a story leaves you hanging, do you like to make up your own ending?
Interesting concept for a song! I didn't know it, but prefer the jazzy Gap Mangione instrumental. As for cliffhangers, they're okay, although a proper conclusion to a story is more to my liking.
I enjoyed both of these versions of the song. And anything about "Autumn" - my favorite season - is sure to be of interest to me.
This one's a bit tough to vote on because... I liked the slower portions of The National Gallery best of all. When the tempo picked up, I didn't care for the drumming. To my ears, it seemed kind of out of whack (or overly intrusive) with the rest of the song and its theme. But I dug all of the vocals.
I really liked the alto sax(?) in the Mangione cover. But that version didn't quite capture the longing ("goldenshadow") of the original. I liked them both, buy I'm voting for THE NATIONAL GALLERY.
>>... "Another autumn is rapidly coming to an end."
Where I live, it is already very ancient history. Spring & Autumn used to last about 6 weeks each. Now, it seems that we get about 6 days of each. And I thinks I knows why.
Goes on too long - like The Wheel of Time? Despite no lyrics, I like Gap Mangione's version better. The first sounds like a weird song and his version sounds like a nice instrumental.
You are certainly right about "The Wheel of Time." I absolutely loved it when it first came out, and I looked forward to each new book... until about the fifth one in the series. I became more and more annoyed that he would not simply resolve it, until finally about book nine I had had enough and refused to read another. Friends soldiered on, foolishly expecting Jordan to finish the darned thing. Then he died. I have not picked it up again even though Brandon Sanderson came on to "finish it." I like him, but he seems almost as periphrastic as Jordan. His Stormlight Archives go on and on like a soap opera for fantasy readers.
Alex, yes to what 6-Gun says. I think I have a copy of that last book he's talking about but I've yet to start reading it. That was a long series for people who like that sort of thing.
I guess the song might be considered psychedelic so that might be kind of weird to some. I like it.
It is an interesting piece, one with which I was unfamiliar. I liked the first one better... EXCEPT for the singing. The singing was enough to have me voting for man who filled the Gap in the Mangione family. His was a nice jazzy version that I enjoyed without an asterisk.
It's an interesting idea, borrowed, of course, from Modeste Mussorgsky's "Pictures at an Exhibition." I wonder what other obscure bands have tried this?
The way you answered IWSG question made me smile. Now onto your first battle of December. Yes, yes, I can feel winter! It's been such an unusually cold Thanksgiving weekend. Brr! I'm not ready for these temperatures.
Your battle song is one that's new to me. I"m giving my vote for the second cover by Gap Mangione.
The song was new to me and I really liked both versions. Even though I didn't hear Chuck playing on the National Gallery version, that gets my vote because the lyrics had a nice 60's vibe and I loved the drummer.
Michael, it's a pretty obscure song--both recordings. I didn't look up to see if Chuck actually plays on the National Gallery album, but there are an array of musicians playing on it.
I like National Gallery! I don't mind cliffhangers as long as they move the story along; as in between chapters. I lose interest waiting for sequels and new seasons. I like your answer, Lee ;-) Merry Christmas!
I don't like books or movies that leave me hanging..it annoys me. So many 70s movies had endings that made me go.." what? That's it!?" Ughhh. As for the dong..I really like the first group...National Gallery. It sounds psychedelic which I love so they get my vote.
I agree with you that cliffhangers can be okay in a series. But like you, I don't like them to go on too long. Except I don't mind them in a mystery series with compelling characters. Happy Holidays!
I”m hearing it from a lot of IWSGers that they don’t like cliff-hangers. I don’t either. Ambiguous endings are something quite different. An editor introduced me to these, quite late on, when I was editing and submitting my novel, Wodka or Tea with Milk.
Ooh, I hadn't heard those songs before! I'm going to have to listen again before voting. Absolute resolution -- I like that phrasing! --Deniz (Google won't let me sign in!)
Hi, Thank you for dropping by my Blog. I am not a cliffhanger fan. After being burned by reading three series that three authors never finished, I stay away from Cliffhangers. Glad you had a nice Thanksgiving. My Thanksgiving was lovely. Have a lovely Second Advent. Shalom shalom
Go ahead and say something. Don't be afraid to speak your mind. I normally try to respond to all comments in the comment section so please remember to check the "Email follow-up comments" box if you want to participate in the comment conversation.
For Battle of the Bands voting the "Anonymous" commenting option has been made available though this version is the least preferred. If voting using "anonymous" please include in your comment your name (first only is okay) and city you are voting from and the reason you chose the artist you did.
If you know me and want to comment but don't want to do it here, then you can send me an email @ jacksonlee51 at aol dot com.
Interesting concept for a song! I didn't know it, but prefer the jazzy Gap Mangione instrumental. As for cliffhangers, they're okay, although a proper conclusion to a story is more to my liking.
ReplyDeleteDebbie D, the entire National Gallery album was a very cool concept that I appreciate even more now.
DeleteVoting starts with Gap Mangione.
Lee
R. LEE BOID ~
ReplyDeleteI enjoyed both of these versions of the song. And anything about "Autumn" - my favorite season - is sure to be of interest to me.
This one's a bit tough to vote on because... I liked the slower portions of The National Gallery best of all. When the tempo picked up, I didn't care for the drumming. To my ears, it seemed kind of out of whack (or overly intrusive) with the rest of the song and its theme. But I dug all of the vocals.
I really liked the alto sax(?) in the Mangione cover. But that version didn't quite capture the longing ("goldenshadow") of the original. I liked them both, buy I'm voting for THE NATIONAL GALLERY.
>>... "Another autumn is rapidly coming to an end."
Where I live, it is already very ancient history. Spring & Autumn used to last about 6 weeks each. Now, it seems that we get about 6 days of each. And I thinks I knows why.
~ D-FensDogG
STMcC, autumn competes with Spring for me. Both have their virtues. Why do you think your seasons are shorter now?
DeleteVoting continues with National Gallery
Lee
I say that is a great tune either way, but I'll take the NG vocals over the straight instrumental.
ReplyDeleteCW, I'm surprised that there are not more covers to be found of this song.
DeleteAnother vote for National GalleryL.
Lee
Goes on too long - like The Wheel of Time?
ReplyDeleteDespite no lyrics, I like Gap Mangione's version better. The first sounds like a weird song and his version sounds like a nice instrumental.
You are certainly right about "The Wheel of Time." I absolutely loved it when it first came out, and I looked forward to each new book... until about the fifth one in the series. I became more and more annoyed that he would not simply resolve it, until finally about book nine I had had enough and refused to read another. Friends soldiered on, foolishly expecting Jordan to finish the darned thing. Then he died. I have not picked it up again even though Brandon Sanderson came on to "finish it." I like him, but he seems almost as periphrastic as Jordan. His Stormlight Archives go on and on like a soap opera for fantasy readers.
DeleteSixgun McItchyfinger
Alex, yes to what 6-Gun says. I think I have a copy of that last book he's talking about but I've yet to start reading it. That was a long series for people who like that sort of thing.
DeleteI guess the song might be considered psychedelic so that might be kind of weird to some. I like it.
A vote for Gap Mangione
Lee
It is an interesting piece, one with which I was unfamiliar. I liked the first one better... EXCEPT for the singing. The singing was enough to have me voting for man who filled the Gap in the Mangione family. His was a nice jazzy version that I enjoyed without an asterisk.
ReplyDeleteIt's an interesting idea, borrowed, of course, from Modeste Mussorgsky's "Pictures at an Exhibition." I wonder what other obscure bands have tried this?
Sixgun McItchyfinger
6-Gun, I'm sure other bands have come up with similar concepts. I'll bet that I probably have a few in my collection.
DeleteA vote for Gap Mangione
Lee
The way you answered IWSG question made me smile. Now onto your first battle of December. Yes, yes, I can feel winter! It's been such an unusually cold Thanksgiving weekend. Brr! I'm not ready for these temperatures.
ReplyDeleteYour battle song is one that's new to me. I"m giving my vote for the second cover by Gap Mangione.
Enjoy the Christmas season, Lee!
Cathy, it's warmed up just a bit here, but I think some cold will be coming.
DeleteA vote for Gap Mangione.
Lee
The song was new to me and I really liked both versions. Even though I didn't hear Chuck playing on the National Gallery version, that gets my vote because the lyrics had a nice 60's vibe and I loved the drummer.
ReplyDeleteMichael, it's a pretty obscure song--both recordings. I didn't look up to see if Chuck actually plays on the National Gallery album, but there are an array of musicians playing on it.
DeleteNational Gallery
Lee
I like National Gallery!
ReplyDeleteI don't mind cliffhangers as long as they move the story along; as in between chapters. I lose interest waiting for sequels and new seasons. I like your answer, Lee ;-) Merry Christmas!
Diedre, I lose interest and forget when I have to wait for a future installment. There are too many things to read and watch as it is.
DeleteA vote for National Gallery.
Lee
The second one is very pleasant on the ears.
ReplyDeleteL.Diane, pleasant is what counts.
DeleteGap Mangione.
Lee
I don't like books or movies that leave me hanging..it annoys me. So many 70s movies had endings that made me go.." what? That's it!?" Ughhh. As for the dong..I really like the first group...National Gallery. It sounds psychedelic which I love so they get my vote.
ReplyDeleteBirgit, I've watched some 70's films that I used to like a lot and then see them now and figure I must have been on something back then. Probably was.
DeletePsychedelic--Yay! National Gallery.
Lee
I preferred the second one, because the horns were more sonorous than the voices. I felt more relaxed with Gap's version, o I'll pick that one.
ReplyDeleteJohn, Gap does have a nice sound.
DeleteGap Mangione
Lee
From Facebook, my cousin Tom votes for...
ReplyDeleteGap Mangione.
Lee
VOTE = GAP MANGIONE
ReplyDeleteI just dug the orchestral, especially brass/woodwind arrangement; it was more evocative of 'autumn wind' than Chuck's vocal arrangement. ~Ed.
Ed, the Gallery is a more artsy approach I'd say.
DeleteA vote for Gap Mangione.
Lee
I agree with you that cliffhangers can be okay in a series. But like you, I don't like them to go on too long. Except I don't mind them in a mystery series with compelling characters. Happy Holidays!
ReplyDeleteNatalie, something ongoing is always an investment. If it's a good investment then I stay with it.
DeleteLee
If I love the story, then, I will like a good cliffhanger, and look forward to the next installment. Happy Holidays!
ReplyDeleteCathrina, I'm the same way: It depends.
DeleteLee
I like an ambiguous ending. But cliffhangers that drag on forever to be resolved just works on my nerves. Happy holidays!
ReplyDeleteRonel visiting for IWSG day Over and Done With. An Author’s Year in Review 2024
Ronel, yeah, it's like let's get this thing over and move on to the next!
DeleteLee
I”m hearing it from a lot of IWSGers that they don’t like cliff-hangers. I don’t either. Ambiguous endings are something quite different. An editor introduced me to these, quite late on, when I was editing and submitting my novel, Wodka or Tea with Milk.
ReplyDeleteRosemary, I'm getting that vibe too. Ambiguous endings work when an author does it well.
DeleteLee
Ooh, I hadn't heard those songs before! I'm going to have to listen again before voting.
ReplyDeleteAbsolute resolution -- I like that phrasing!
--Deniz (Google won't let me sign in!)
Deniz, any resolution should be absolute I think otherwise I don't think you can call it a resolution. But it is fun to say.
DeleteLee
I vote for Gap. I've never heard that phrase, "ambiguous ending", but I like it. I think both those and cliffhangers have their time and place.
ReplyDeleteJennifer, I thought it was a common phrase in literary terms. Ambiguous ending is an appropriate designation sometimes.
DeleteA vote for Gap Mangione
Lee
Hi,
ReplyDeleteThank you for dropping by my Blog. I am not a cliffhanger fan. After being burned by reading three series that three authors never finished, I stay away from Cliffhangers.
Glad you had a nice Thanksgiving. My Thanksgiving was lovely.
Have a lovely Second Advent.
Shalom shalom
Pat, it would be pretty bad to invest into something that never has a real ending. I've followed some TV shows like that.
DeleteLee
Olga, teasers work for me too. I used to love how the old Hardy Boys and Tom Swift books used to do that. It worked for me when I was a kid.
ReplyDeleteLee
The results are in! Come see:
ReplyDeletehttps://tossingitout.blogspot.com/2024/12/prevailing-winds-botb-results.html
Lee